Consulting Rainmakers

Nobody fixes a toxic workplace with training

Catherine Mattice · Civility Partners ·

Catherine Mattice is the founder and CEO of Civility Partners, a consulting firm that turns around toxic workplace cultures, and the author of Navigating a Toxic Workplace For Dummies. This Consulting Rainmakers episode, hosted by Mikulas Zach, is about one idea, in Catherine's words: Nobody fixes a toxic workplace with training.

Can training fix a toxic workplace culture?

Catherine Mattice: No. When people are disrespectful they already know how to behave and are choosing not to because of the organization, so her firm steers clients toward culture change rather than a one-off training.

Watch on YouTubeSpotifyApple Podcasts

About Catherine Mattice

Catherine was working in HR at a company with a bully on staff when she started her master's degree. A research project in her first semester led her to the phrase "workplace bullying", and everything she did in graduate school, her thesis included, followed from it. She started Civility Partners on the other side of grad school, wrote her first book, Back Off, and taught college as an adjunct professor to pay the bills until the firm was doing well enough that she didn't need to. She has since trained Chevron's HR business partners and NASA's ombuds on handling bullying, and she runs a sales process built to steer clients away from the one-off training they came in asking for.

Expect to learn why culture doesn't come from the top, why a training won't fix a team that already knows how to be respectful, the one question she asks to find the 20 percent that shapes a culture, how Civility Partners runs a two-year culture engagement, why she won't compete on price, and much more…

Catherine Mattice: LinkedIn · Website

Chapters

  1. 0:00Intro
  2. 0:37From HR to workplace bullying
  3. 2:23Why she wrote Back Off
  4. 4:29What makes good and bad culture
  5. 7:43The 20 percent that shapes culture
  6. 8:19From first call to strategy call
  7. 11:02The two-year culture engagement
  8. 12:06Training Chevron and NASA
  9. 13:30Dream big and don't compete on price
  10. 18:15Who they help most
  11. 19:13Where to find Catherine

Transcript

Machine transcript of the conversation between Catherine Mattice and Mikulas Zach, lightly cleaned. Spelling of names and terms may be off.

Mikulas Zach

Welcome back to another podcasting episode. joining me today is Katrin Matisse, the CEO and founder at Civility Partners. Katrin, it's good to have you on.

Catherine Mattice

Happy to be here.

Mikulas Zach

So tell me how did all this all get started? You know you you you taught at national university, then Southwestern College while running Civility Partners. What kind of made you stop splitting your time and go all in on the firm and what do you do?

Catherine Mattice

Yeah. so I'll back it up a little and talk about how I started Civility Partners first. I listened to the universe, that's the answer. So I I was internal HR working for a company that had a difficult person, a bully if if you will, and I started getting my master's degree while I was working there, which was always the plan. but the the universe had me in my very first semester in graduate school. I was in ethnography, which is a kind of research where you're the researchers, you know, in it. And my other class was called the dark side of communication and it was about stalking and domestic violence and dark communication. So I'm thinking, you know, as a working grad student, I can I need a topic for both. Classes. So one set of research to write two papers and ended up coming across the phrase workplace bullying. And it turns out there's tons of research on this topic, and America's actually pretty far behind. Europe is much more advanced at looking at what it's off it's often called mobbing or psychological harassment in your part of the world. anyway, so everything I did in graduate school was on that topic. wrote my thesis on that topic and started my business on the other side of grad school and wrote a book pretty quickly called Back Off. and so then I started teaching college as an adjunct or part time professor to, you know, pay the bills while I built up Civility Partners. And eventually I got to a point where Civility Partners was doing well enough that I didn't need to teach anymore.

Mikulas Zach

Right, and back to your book, what would be kind of like the one key lesson or one thing that you would like to share if people didn't h hear it?

Catherine Mattice

Yeah. so the book is called Back Off, and I wrote it honestly more for myself. It it was an opportunity for me to take all of the academic information I'd learned about bullying and start to translate it into, you know, more more normal speak. and so I I really did it as a way to help myself process. everything I learned and start to figure out my voice around this unique topic. and secondly, you know, I was right out of graduate school, so I felt like I needed credibility and the book gave me that. So anybody who wants to write a book, recognize it's not, you know, unless it's a New York Times bestseller, you're never gonna make money off of it. But if you're starting a business, writing a book with your point of view However, even if it's short, back off was pretty long. It didn't need to be that long. Even if it's just thirty or fifty or a hundred pages, it's something to give people to say, I know what I'm talking about.

Mikulas Zach

Yeah, yeah. And I've I've heard a lot of stories about books being like a great sort of source of trust where you know you can you can display it and you can have people read it and who knows if if if they might reach out if they like the whole concept around the book. tell me more about culture because I think it's very discussed topic in in all industries. what makes good culture and on the opposite side what makes bad culture?

Catherine Mattice

Yeah. So cultures I define it as the way people in your organization understand the w the world around them and the way they behave as a result of that understanding. And culture definitely can feel very abstract. It can feel like something that's hard to get a hold of. but the thing is it exists in your organization whether you focus on it or not or whether you're strategic about it or not. So you might as well be strategic about it and use it as an advantage. And a healthy culture has to be intentional. Just like I mean you think about I know you're I don't know if you have kids or anybody listening, you know, you have to be intentional about parenting. You have to ask yourself, what's the message I need to get across in this moment when the kid's having a a tempered tantrum or when your teenager is telling you about something happening at school. You know, it's it's very intentional what you're thinking about and wanting to make sure you get across and culture's a lot like that. It's you It as an entrepreneur, as an organization that's growing, or even as a manager in an organization, you have the ability to influence culture because culture is about our daily interactions. A lot of people say culture comes from the top. That's BS. It does not come from the top. Certainly, the top can put resources towards culture or not. but Again, culture exists within our daily interactions. So anybody honestly has the ability to influence culture. toxic or unhealthy culture, it's sort of like mold. It starts to grow in the gaps between what leaders say they want to have happen or how they want people to behave, and how the organization actually functions to support that behavior. So we describe culture as existing in the oil, the organization's behavior, individual behavior, and leadership behavior. and so one way to be strategic about a healthy culture is, for example, if you say, I want everybody in the organization to be respectful to each other. But as a leadership team, maybe you let some high performer be disrespectful. Now there's misalignment. And maybe the organization isn't measuring people on whether or not they're being respectful like they would other job tasks or performance metrics. and so that's an example of leaders saying one thing about how they want people to behave, but everything else is misaligned. So they're not setting people up for success for that.

Mikulas Zach

Got it, got it. And if you could give you've probably heard about the the Parrot rule, the eighty twenty. what is the twenty in your opinion when it comes to building a strong culture that is aligned?

Catherine Mattice

no one's asked me that before. I need to think that through. Honestly, I think it's the way the organization behaves. So the it's just so often organizations say this is what we want, but they have policies or technology or processes in place that really hit in really hinder people's ability to live that, right? So the organization needs to stop and ask itself my favorite question, what are we doing or not doing that facilitates this behavior? That's the twenty percent.

Mikulas Zach

Right, right. And say that I run a organization and I reach out to civility partners and I'm asking whether this makes sense to work or not. Tell talk to me about kind of the first steps that you take from kind of the first meeting to a collaboration.

Catherine Mattice

Yep. So we we start with well if you're ask are you asking more about kind of like my sales process or more about our work with clients?

Mikulas Zach

I think those both are tied together. So you can pick you can pick how you want to.

Catherine Mattice

Yes, they are. Okay, I'll start with the sales process, I guess. yeah, so I I really get a lot of leads by speaking, doing podcasts and webinars, getting my message out there about what I think about how culture works, you know. and then we'll get the the email that someone's interested in talking to us because they have some problem they'd like solved and they think we can solve it. so I have a a teammate here, Rebecca. She does a discovery call to find out kind of more about what's going on. And often she ends up s trying to set them straight a little bit. So for example, people will call and say, We want to do a training around a respectful work environment, and she'll say why and they'll say, We have, you know, a department that everybody's kind of being disrespectful, there's some conflict in there. And so then she's able to say, well, a training's not going to solve that problem. They already know how to be respectful. They're choosing not to because of the organization. So she starts to set them straight so that when then the second call is the call with me, where it's more of a strategy call. And now they've been primed to know that I can talk to them about training, but I'm going to try to talk them into something that's more of a solution than the one they had in mind. So that's really a brainstorming call. just hearing more about things and talking through different options. and then from there we send a scope of work and then we have a third call to kind of finalize that scope of work and and maybe they say, No, we really just want to do the training and it's like, okay. or they'll say, Thank goodness we're not doing the training, let's do all this other stuff. so once a client says yes, it in terms of culture transformation, we start off with discoveries. So just to keep using that example, we would probably do some listening sessions in that department, find out what's going on, why people are being disrespectful towards one another, find out what role the organization plays in that. And then we're able to create a report and with a ton of recommendations for the organization. We also have our own proprietary survey. So if it's a large enough department or the whole company you know, we also want to do that survey. And our survey is called a climate assessment. It looks at a variety of constructs. and then from there we engage with the client for about two years and help them implement their roadmap to changing culture. And really our goal is to teach them how to get control of their culture, how to see it as a strategic item on their strategic plan and how how you can make it not abstract, you know how you can really quantify it, measure its usefulness to the business and all of the things.

Mikulas Zach

Right. Yeah, that sounds great. And is that how Chevron and NASA actually collaborated with you through speaking events?

Catherine Mattice

Yeah, just like that. They both they both s had a representative that saw me speak at a conference. Chevron was interesting. They actually that that project was every year Chevron brings all of its HR business partners from all around the world to do a con like an internal conference for all of them. And so they asked me to be a a speaker there. So I ran a workshop on bullying and what it is and how to coach people who are bullies and taught Chevron's HR business partners how to manage bullying. And then NASA, similar there they have an ombuds program and the over at NASA they asked us to also train the ombuds there at NASA how to detect bullying, how to help people learn to stand up for themselves, how to help people navigate that situation, basically.

Mikulas Zach

Hmm. So you have what 18 years building civility partners? then you have a book, then you have courses. tell me if you could go back to the very beginning with all with all of the hindsight that you have right now, what would you do differently if you would be starting in today's day and age?

Catherine Mattice

Yep, almost. Dang near, yeah. b dream big. Dream big. I think I even to this day, my own not like I believe in myself and I believe in my team and we've come a long way. I'd like us to be a lot bigger and I recognize that I it's my own self-limiting beliefs. It's hard to imagine being a $10 million consulting firm, you know, and it's not about the 10 million. It just means that's more workplaces we're influencing. and it's hard, you know, people tell me all the time I'm a really great speaker. And someone told me the other day, you should be charging 20 grand for your speaking gigs. And it's like, really? You think so? You know, so and that's not a great reaction. So the, you know, think big and recognize your value and St stay in your lane. You know, we focus on broken toxic work environments. We're not all things to all people. we don't compete on price. If somebody asks in that discovery call, you know, in the the first call, what's the price? The answer from Rebecca is we don't compete on price. And if that's part of your decision, you know, I'm not gonna move you on to the next round or the next call. so that that's my answer. But Know that if you're the expert on the thing, then you're worth something, whatever that topic is that you're the expert on, and believe in yourself and believe people will pay money to get access to whatever solution you're offering.

Mikulas Zach

Yeah, that's spot on. And I think like a lot of people don't realize this when they go, for example, with the cheaper option that it costs them more on the long horizon. Since they might not deliver that solution or you know, they might not have such a strong delivery or just experience in general, hence why they are cheaper, right? So

Catherine Mattice

Yeah, yeah. Well, and it's about value, right? And so we try to talk a lot about that. And we'll we during our sales process try to really help companies see how much they've already spent on the problem. And so sometimes, you know, they say, Never mind, we're just we don't have the budget or the time right now. And so then I'll respond and say, Yeah, but we just talked about how you've already spent a million dollars on this. Are you sure that's the answer? or yeah, if it's training and they say, well, we're just gonna go to the cheap cheaper option, it's like our training brings a lot of value. We don't just show up and train, we have a whole there, it's a whole thing. it's all about helping you shift culture, even if it is just just one training. so like if the goal is just to drop knowledge on people that they'll never talk about again, then fine, go with that cheaper option. If the goal is to actually change behavior, that's what you're paying for. It's not the training, it's the outcome.

Mikulas Zach

Right, right, yeah. So you you mentioned growth. everyone wants to grow. I think there is not a single person on this earth that doesn't want that. So are there any like specific goals that you have when it comes to you know the next twelve, twenty-four months?

Catherine Mattice

Yeah, you know, civility partners is ever evolving and I think my goal for the next twelve months is to hone in on the value that we bring, potentially I don't know. I saw a webinar the other day and she was talking about kill the baby. Like if you have too many services, then it's hard to sell any of them. So that definitely stuck in my head because we have a variety of avenues. So yeah, just I'm gonna continue to move outside of the business so that I can build the business and do speaking gigs and be the chief cheerleader for civility partners and I'm really working on handing my operations over to my ops person, which can be hard. It's so easy to just like, I'll do this. But really, really, really trying to pull away from that. So

Mikulas Zach

Right. Well that sounds like a great goal. Speaking about kind of industries, w who do you think civility partners can help the most in terms of kind of the situation or the type of company?

Catherine Mattice

Yeah, so s incivility and workplace bullying tends to exist in certain industries more than others, though any industry certainly can have it. healthcare, higher ed, government tends manufacturing or construction, that kind of blue-collar sector, tend to be where there's more toxicity. but our clients have ranged from restaurants to hotels to IT to software development to aerospace, you know, we we've really been in a variety of industries over the years. Where there's people, there's problems.

Mikulas Zach

Okay. so wrapping this up, Katrin. if people would like to, you know, reach out or check out Civility Partners, what's the best place?

Catherine Mattice

Yep. you can find Katherine Mattis if you just Google me. Our website is civilitypartners.com. My newest book is on Amazon. It's called Navigating a Toxic Workplace for Dummies, which is a a series of books that Wiley puts out, the Four Dummies series. I'm on LinkedIn. I'm everywhere.

Mikulas Zach

Okay, sounds great. Well this was Katrin Matisse from Civility Partners. Thank you for listening and Katrin, thank you for joining.

Catherine Mattice

Thank you.