Consulting Rainmakers

Why great interviewers still make bad hires

Craig della Penna · Aesop Partners ·

Craig della Penna is the Managing Partner and Founder of Aesop Partners. This Consulting Rainmakers episode, hosted by Mikulas Zach, is about one idea, in Craig's words: Why great interviewers still make bad hires.

In this conversation, Craig explains why getting clear on the job matters more than interview skill, why so many investors still skip a hard look at the leadership they are buying, and why the promise of AI runs ahead of what it delivers today.

Watch on YouTubeSpotifyApple Podcasts

About Craig della Penna

Craig della Penna started his consulting career at the Boston Consulting Group, where he rose to principal, before leaving in 2011 to join Green Peak Partners as its fifth consultant. Over the next seven years he helped grow the firm and led its organizational due diligence group, which grew five times while he was there. He then founded Aesop Partners, named after Aesop's Fables, the first book his dad read to him, with a client who offered to be his anchor tenant, and today advises private equity firms on leadership decisions from diligence to hiring. He is the co-creator of the Cipher framework and author of Cipher, and his team built HireBest, a software platform that uses AI to help companies design roles and run structured interviews.

Expect to learn how one client trained 500 hiring managers and saw a 50% drop in first-year failures, how a CFO covered for a weak finance team so well that his investors never saw it, what private equity firms pay for in diligence and what they leave out, why Aesop took a hundred versions before trusting AI with client reports, what nobody tells you about running your own firm, and why structure and intentional thought beat gut feel when selecting talent, and much more…

Craig della Penna: LinkedIn · Website

Chapters

  1. 0:00Cold open
  2. 1:05Welcome
  3. 1:24From BCG To Founding Aesop Partners
  4. 6:29The Cipher Framework
  5. 9:41Where Private Equity Hiring Goes Wrong
  6. 12:15The Leadership Diligence Most Deals Skip
  7. 14:13The Promise And Reality Of AI
  8. 18:21What Running Your Own Firm Really Takes
  9. 20:49There Is A Science To Selecting Talent
  10. 21:48Aesop's Fables Applied To Business
  11. 23:10Where To Find Craig della Penna

Transcript

Machine transcript of the conversation between Craig della Penna and Mikulas Zach, lightly cleaned. Spelling of names and terms may be off.

Mikulas Zach

So joining me today is Craig Delapena, the managing partner and founder at ASOL Partners. Craig, thank you for coming on and sharing your story today.

Craig della Penna

Well thanks for having me, Mick. I'm really pleased to be on the podcast today and share my story with your listeners.

Mikulas Zach

So to get us going, right? you were a principal at the Boston Consulting Group, and then you spent some time at the Green Peak Partners. what made you found Ace of Partners? What's the story?

Craig della Penna

Yeah. So, you know, and it there's never just with any career transition, there's never just one story, right? There's always a bunch of different factors. for me, when I, you know, I left BCG for a variety of factors. Some was that I had a a three year old at home who was saying, Daddy, how come you're never home? like the other daddies. Some were that the BCG was really focused on at the time I left, which was twenty eleven, they were focused on becoming one of the biggest consulting firms in the world. And I thought, well, That's nice, but there are bigger firms in BCG already. bigger isn't isn't the issue to me. Better is the issue. and what I loved about BCG is that we were a great SWAT team of really smart people who would parachute into a situation that felt impossible to the company that was dealing with it and we'd figure something out. And so as BCG started to go a little bit towards the bigger, and they've been super successful on that. And I love my time at BCG. If you have an opportunity ever to work for BCG, you should grab it and jump in. It was an amazing learning environment. But for me, they were going in a different direction that I was really passionate about. And at the same time, I had someone who had been trying to recruit me for a few years. And the thing I loved most at BCG was the human side, right? So coming up with a beautiful strategy, that's great.

Mikulas Zach

most of BCG was a human side, right? So coming up with a beautiful strategy, that's great. But when strategies don't work, it's because the humans weren't alive.

Craig della Penna

But when strategies don't work, it's because the humans weren't aligned. And I'd learned at BCG how to do some of that human alignment. And and that was recruited by Green Peak, who was all about the human side in private equity. I thought, huh, well, that's interesting. Let's let's go there. And it was massive shift, right? I I think the Boston office of BCG alone was several hundred people when I left. And I had a nice spot there. And I went to a firm where I was the fifth consultant. so tiny little firm. but It was the right move for me at the time. grew that over the next seven years. But we got to the same point where Green Peak was looking to go after bigger clients. They were looking to go after bigger projects. And I love the small niche projects I was doing for the middle market clients in private equity. and there were a few other things that happened. We had our first leadership turnover situation. We were all starting to think about what's new for us and what's the future for us. When I realized that at the end of the day, I was going to start a new job. I was either going to start a new job at Green Peak, helping them build in a different direction than they'd done before, or I could start a new job at ASOP, founding my own company in my own image and what was important to me. So, you know what, let's give that a shot. And I had a client who was very eager to keep working with me. And so they said, look, we'll be your anchor tenant and we'll help you, you know, get off the ground. And it worked out beautifully. And it's been what now, eight years since then just continual nice, nice growth.

Mikulas Zach

Hmm. No, that's great. And what was the transition like? Because you know I I talked to a lot of people and a lot of people seemed to say that it's hard at the beginning because you no longer have someone that's providing you on a monthly basis a paycheck, basically, regardless of what you do. right. So did you also had kind of similar feelings.

Craig della Penna

little bit, but I was incredibly fortunate where Green Peak, JP, the the founder there, he we left on great terms. He understood that he wanted to go in a d different direction than I was looking to do. he had about two months, two and a half months notice before I left. so there was a nice easy glide path. I continued to train people even before I left, trying to help him transition all my relationships, except for a handful that he said, Craig, these aren't really part of our strategy going forward, and they're more your clients anyways. You can take these clients. And so we we had a nice transition there. Long story short, I finished on a Friday as a Green Peak employee. I started as an ASOP employee on the Monday. And on Tuesday I was flying out to my first project. And I was really fortunate that I I had issues with not being able to get the work done rather rather than where is all the work going to come from.

Mikulas Zach

And I was really fortunate that I I had issues with not being able to get done rather than where is all the work going to come from it was demand management rather than and supply issues, of of clients that is. Well that's a great problem to have, Craig. I'm very

Craig della Penna

It was demand management rather than than supply issues, of of clients, that is. So It it I'm very fortunate. I was very lucky from that standpoint. So yes.

Mikulas Zach

Yes. So one thing that piqued my interest is a framework that you've built called the the Cypher framework. so can you tell me how did that come together and what does the framework do and help?

Craig della Penna

Gladly. So when I started ASOP, one of the things I had learned from helping grow the prior consulting firm is that professional services firms are tough to grow. At the end of the day, you have to find really high quality talent and train them up. And they can always choose to leave. And at that point, you'll always have a a bit of a loss to the company because so much of of your your assets are the people. And

Mikulas Zach

They can always choose to leave. And at that point, you'll always have a bit of a loss to the company. Because so much of of your assets are the people. And there's only so much you can ever charge because it's a weight times time business. So I knew there had to be something that was more productized at it at ASL.

Craig della Penna

there's only so much you can ever charge because it's a rate times time business. So I knew there had to be something that was more productized at a at ASOP. And I had a a client who had a specific need for training. They really wanted to be able to do the assessments that we do. They wanted to be able to interview much better across their company rather than just hire us for them. And frankly they needed thousand assessments if we were to do it. And there's no way I could ever provide a thousand assessments. That wasn't going to happen. So I put the time in back starting in 2019 to start to develop the cipher framework, which is part of the broader hire best methodology on how to do really high quality structured interviewing. For this one client, we trained up something like 500 hiring managers from Boston to Brisbane to Santa Barbara.

Mikulas Zach

On how to do high-quality structured are doing. for this one client, we trained up something like 500 hiring managers from Boston to Brisbane to Santa Barbara to India, China, I mean all over the world. And it was the first time that they ever hit their hiring goals because we're able to teach them a more efficient way to hire

Craig della Penna

To India, China, I mean all over the world. And it was the first time that they ever hit their hiring goals because we were able to teach them a more efficient way to hire that also resulted in higher quality. The next year they had a 50% reduction in first-year attrition. So think about this. The first time they've ever hired so many people, 1,300 people were hired the year that we taught them this, with a 50% drop in first-year failures.

Mikulas Zach

with a 50% drop in first year failures. So it was really quite strong. And it was the cipher was a key part of that. Getting clear, what the cipher does is it gets clear on what's important in this role. And it you try to focus to a one-sentence explanation of this is what the job is all about. That's a charge. The outcome is how will we measure success in the role?

Craig della Penna

So it was really quite strong. And it was the cipher was a key part of that. Getting clear, what the cipher does is it gets clear on what's important in this role. And it you try to focus to a one-sentence explanation of this is what the job is all about. That's the charge. The outcome is how will we measure success in the role? And then you have deliverables and efforts. You have five to seven deliverables with three or four efforts underneath each.

Mikulas Zach

And then you have deliverables and efforts. You have five to seven deliverables. You have three or four efforts underneath each that explain how you're going to achieve that outcome. It creates a nice little acronym, the way. So you have code, the charge, the outcome, the deliverables, the efforts. You have those five to seven deliverables in there that you prioritize to clear on what matters most.

Craig della Penna

That explain how you're going to achieve that outcome and creates a nice little acronym, by the way. So you have code, the charge, the outcome, the deliverables, and the efforts. You have those five to seven deliverables in there that you prioritize, get really clear on what matters most. And then you just follow that cipher to look at have I learned from my interviews data that would predict success against it? If so, yes, great, make that higher. If you haven't, then you either need to do some more interviewing or decide that this person just can't succeed at this role.

Mikulas Zach

Then you either need to do some more interviewing or decide that this person just can't succeed at the top. Hmm. When you look at the way that PE hires, what do you think are like the biggest missed opportunities for most of these firms when it comes to their hiring? No, there's

Craig della Penna

You know, there's a whole ho when you say missed opportunities, I assume also in there is mistakes and things that they just when things go wrong, how come? Oftentimes it is not taking enough time to think about the role. It's it's why my first book was cipher rather than hire best. You know, I I could write a book on how to interview well, but that's secondary to really thinking about the job.

Mikulas Zach

I assume also there's mistakes and things that they just when things go wrong Oftentimes it is not taking enough time to think about rule. It's it's why my first book was cipher rather than higher best. You know, I I could write a book on how to interview well, but that's secondary to really thinking about the job. If you've if you've thought about what matters most in this job and you create that cipher, it's a lot easier for an average interviewer to be more effective if you know what you're looking for.

Craig della Penna

If you've if you've thought about what matters most in this job and you create that cipher, it's a lot easier for an average interview to be more effective because you know what you're looking for. Whereas if I get great interview training and I'm really perfect at running an interview, but you and I don't agree on what we're actually looking for, I have a much lower chance of being successful there than if I took the time and just figured out what really matters in this role.

Mikulas Zach

Whereas if I get great interview training and I'm really perfect at running an interview, but you and I don't agree on what we're actually looking for, I have a much lower chance of being successful there than if I took the time and just figured out what really matters most of me.

Craig della Penna

And it's it's interesting. I've had situations where I'll talk to the investors. We're there's one situation we're looking to replace the CFO. The CFO had quit. We need a new CFO. And I asked the investors, okay, how is financial planning and analysis? How is that function doing? Yeah, I think we're good. We we're very happy with the information we see. Because from their standpoint, the CFO before had been providing what they needed. When we talked to the CEO, they said,

Mikulas Zach

And it's it's interesting. I've had situations where I'll talk to the investors where we're there's one situation we're looking to replace the CFO. The CFO had quit, we need a new CFO. And I asked the investors, okay, how is financial planning and analysis? How is that function doing? I think we're good. We we're very happy with the information we see. Because from their standpoint, the CFO before has been what we need. When we talked to the CEO, they said, we absolutely need a better FPMA-based CF CFO this time. He wasn't leveraging our team at all. They're not good. And since he's been gone, it's been a major issue in the company. And the problem was the the the private equity leaders felt that they knew what was going on in the company because the CFO was doing a very good job of covering that efficiency himself.

Craig della Penna

We absolutely need a better FPNA-based CF CFO this time. He wasn't leveraging our team at all. They're not good. And since he's been gone, it's been a major issue in the company. And the problem was the the the private equity leaders felt that they knew what was going on in the company because the CFO was doing a very good job of covering that deficiency himself. But if they had gotten more thoughtful around what they really needed in the role.

Mikulas Zach

Hm. had gotten more thoughtful around what they really used to role, they would have been able to get to a better outcome faster. We did get them there, but they had to to kiss a lot of problems on their on their way to getting to the right camp. Yeah. You know, I think so many of these issues come down to just misalignment between people.

Craig della Penna

they would have been able to get to a better outcome faster. We did get them there, but they had to to kiss a lot of frogs on their on their way to getting to the right candidate.

Mikulas Zach

Like almost ninety percent, the bigger the organization, like the the more it's about people. I feel like and that's what I've heard. what about things like due diligence? what do you think? Yeah, I've so I've been in this field now for fifteen years. When I when I first started in twenty eleven, there were a smattering of of people like me.

Craig della Penna

Completely agree. It's a great question. You know, I've so I've been in this field now for 15 years. When I when I first started in 2011, there were a smattering of people like me who would do executive assessments, meaning, if you're looking to hire a CEO or a CFO, let's hire someone to interview that person and make sure they're going to do well. But there is very little organizational due diligence being done.

Mikulas Zach

Executive assessments, meaning if you're looking to hire a CEO or a CFO, let's hire someone to interview that person and make sure we're going to do well. But there was very little organizational due diligence taking done. They'd pay millions of dollars to the accountants, to the lawyers, to the investment bankers, maybe to an IT services firm to understand the systems.

Craig della Penna

Right? They'd pay millions of dollars to the accountants, to the lawyers, to the investment bankers, maybe to an IT services firm to understand the systems, but they wouldn't get an outside opinion on the leadership, either because they didn't know that such a thing existed. And I still find that today. I'll still pitch my services to private equity firms who, wow, I didn't even know such a thing existed. But then I run across some who say, well, Craig, that's my job.

Mikulas Zach

They wouldn't get an outside opinion on the leadership. Either because they didn't know that such a thing existed. And I still find that today. I'll still pitch my services to find that because I didn't even know such a thing existed. but then I ran across some who say, Well, Craig, that's my job. I should be able to pick and choose the the leadership teams.

Craig della Penna

I should be able to to pick and choose the the leadership teams. And they're right that it's their job to have the final say on that. But if you have someone who's an expert in that, to be able to tap into them to figure out what's really the talent quality in this company, and can they actually accomplish the strategy that we're going to set out for this company once we've invested in it? so it's it's an area that has grown so much. Yeah, while I was at Green Peak, I led our organizational due diligence group and we grew five times over the time period I was there, which was great, but it's still just a small part of the market, and so many private equity firms don't do formal human capital diligence. and those that do mostly just do executive interviews to understand a person rather than understanding how the whole company works.

Mikulas Zach

Hmm. Now cr Craig, it wouldn't be a podcast and a conversation without mentioning AI because I think it's just everywhere. And so I'm curious to to hear how are you using AI at ASOP, whether it's internally or externally? What is kind of like your stance?

Craig della Penna

We're we're using it all over the place. And I have I have a multitude of stances on AI. I think if you're not doing something with AI today, you're gonna miss the boat. You need to be engaging with AI. It's just too, too important a technology to not be engaging with, to learn about and figuring out what it can do for you. At so I'll put a stake in the ground over there. I'm also gonna put a stake in the ground over here, though, that I think the The promise of AI is a lot brighter than the delivery can actually be. It's really easy to hear, yeah, I just spent the weekend whipping up an app. And you can do that, right? It's possible. But the quality of that app after that weekend of work will be blah. Right. And if you invest the next several weekends or several weeks, you can get good quality, but it takes that level of investment. You have to put into it.

Mikulas Zach

Of AI is a lot greater than the delivery can actually be. It's really easy to hear, yeah, I just spent the weekend whipping up an app. You can do that, right? It's possible. But the quality of that app after that weekend of work will be black. And if you invest the next several weekends or several weeks, you can get good quality. But it takes that level of investment to put into it.

Craig della Penna

for us, we have an internal and an external product around AI. So we actually have a platform that teaches people and then helps people do interviews. So that training methodology I first started when I started ASOP has morphed now over time into an actual software platform where we use AI to help you design your cipher. We'll use AI to transcribe all your interviews, to suggest some good questions, to look at all the data analysis. But it's always done with a suggestion. and it's taken thousands of hours of work with internal and external technology technology resources to get really dialed in and provide good intelligence on a question, you might ask it. internally, we also we're starting to use it now for for some of our report assistance, but again, they're our first versions, our first hundred versions.

Mikulas Zach

So internally we also we're starting to use it now for some of our report assistance. But again, their our first versions, our first hundred versions of reports coming out were just too long for me I I I refuse to do a bad job for my clients, so if it's going to take me more time manually, we're gonna do that. but we're now finally at the point.

Craig della Penna

reports coming out were just too wrong for me to really trust. I I I I refuse to do a bad job for my clients. So if it's going to take me more time manually, we're gonna do that. but we're now finally at the point where it's delivering really good it intelligence and so it's it's close to matching a human. So we're now trusting it more and and bringing that in and starting to get some efficiency gains.

Mikulas Zach

So we're now trusting it more and starting to get sensitive data. You know, AI is if you use it for a short amount of time, you don't realize this, but as I spend a lot of time in chatting with it, I realize how positively inclined it it it is and how it is able to fool you. and it seems like it knows everything and it says things with such a confidence that yeah you have to keep your eyes open at all time because the amount of times where i i thought it's saying something that was true and then i realized later on that it's it's complete horse was just yeah and it's w as we what you you were saying around kind of the the vibe coding as people call it I think there is this study that came out that like ninety-five percent of AI pilots fail in production and I think it's exactly what you're saying. Like you can get so qu much faster from zero to one, but to go from one to hundred it takes such an amount of effort. as you mentioned earlier, you started in 2018, I believe. so what what have you learned that your your crack that's listening to this wouldn't wouldn't believe

Craig della Penna

Yes. With ASOP, yep. good question. you know, I've learned that some of my friends who are also competitors who tried to entice me to just join them. And I said, no, I want to do my own thing. And they're said, well, it's a lot of work to run your own company. And I thought they were just trying to get me to come work for them. No, that was good advice that I just ignored. It is a lot of work to run your own company. There's a lot of stress. You alluded to it. I didn't have the stress starting up. in terms of where's the revenue coming in. But now I have seven people on the team. I I consider that a very solemn obligation that I've got seven families to provide for. So I need to find a way to make sure the revenue is coming in so I can meet my payroll. I can meet my and and that is hard. There's a level of stress there that you have to accept and take on and risk. but you know, I I thought I would enjoy.

Mikulas Zach

But I've got seven to provide for. I need to find a way to make sure the revenue is coming in so can meet my payroll, I can meet my

Craig della Penna

being my own boss, I had no idea how much I would truly love the the freedom intellectually of having an idea, getting a little creative and saying, hey, let's try this. Let's go. That it's it's so much better than it when I was one of several partners, which no knock to my partners at all. But in a partnership you have to align. You all have to agree. when when you're the the main entrepreneur

Mikulas Zach

In a partnership you have to align. You all have to agree. when when you're the the main entrepreneur, you can make a bet and be a little bit more creative. You need your team around you to align and agree. my team is great, they're smart, they're creative, and they tolerate me, so that's wonderful. But

Craig della Penna

you can make a bet and be a little bit more creative. You need your team around you to align and agree. my team is great, they're smart, they're creative, and they tolerate me. So, you know, it's wonderful. But you know it's it's just the flexibility to try something new and be a little bit creative is so much more than I thought it would be and it's it's been really valuable to me.

Mikulas Zach

Yeah, it's just the flexibility to try something new and you look at creative. It's so much more than a file feeding that's the final and it's sort of like a double sided sword, right? because you have the freedom, but at the same time, as you were saying, it's now your people rely on you much more. So what would be the main takeaway that listeners should take from today's episode with you? Sure. So I would say that when you think about talent from your company, whether you're a CEO who's listening or private equity leader, there is a science to selecting talent, whether you're talking about during diligence or in hiring situations. And

Craig della Penna

Correct. Sure. So I would say that when you think about talent in a company, whether you're a CEO that who's listening or a private equity leader, there is a science to selecting talent, whether you're talking about during diligence or in hiring situations. And that science comes down to structure and intentional thought. And there's more to it than that, as my PhDs and my team would tell me. But

Mikulas Zach

That science comes down to structure and intentional thought. And there's more to it than that, as my PhDs team have me. But structure and intentional if you put those into your decisions and really think through what do I need to know for to to get the right answer on this question, and how am I going to structure my approach to get it, you'll do far better than percent of the people out there. Right. But the best thing you should do is.

Craig della Penna

structure and intentional thought. If you put those two into your decisions and really think through what do I need to know for the to to get the right answer on this question and how am I going to structure my approach to get it, you'll do far better than ninety percent of the people out there. But the best thing you should do is just call Aesop.

Mikulas Zach

Of course, of course. as I'm watching your your shelf with with your book, is there another book that's coming or are you right now

Craig della Penna

right now, no, but in the future, yes. So the book that I originally wanted to write when I first started Aesop, because Aesop is is a reference to Aesop's Fables. And that those Aesop's Fables was the first book my dad read to me. so it's a deeply personal choice of the name, but it's also a professional strong name because it's it's the power of a short story to change behavior. Right. When you when you hear one of Aesop's fables and you hear about you know the fox and the sour grapes, and you see that fox say, the grapes were probably no good at all, you're Well, I I do that sometimes too. Why do I do that? No, they were good grapes. I just need to have a better attitude around that. so the book I want to write is to apply Aesop's fables to business. And I actually I wrote an article over the course of the summer on that. It was the most fun article I wrote so far. So expect that in the future, a a take on ASOP's fables applied to business and just trying to help people learn more about business in an easy, easy, accessible manner.

Mikulas Zach

So expect that in the future. A a take on ASOF stables applied to business, and just trying to help people learn more about business in an easy easy accessible manner. Well, there you go, guys. So what's the best place to find you, Craig? The best place to find two great places. You can go to ASOF

Craig della Penna

The best place to find me, there's two great places. You can go to asoppartners.com, which is a soppartners.com, or you can go to higherbest.ai. That's h-i-re-e-best.ai. depending if you're interested in learning more about our software platform, then you're going to go to higher best. If you're interested in learning more about our consulting, you go to ASOPPartners. We'd love to see you at either.

Mikulas Zach

Amazing. So links are down below and Craig thank you for coming on and sharing your insights. Thank you very much so

Craig della Penna

Thank you, Mick. It's just so natural and wonderful to be a part of this podcast. And I just congratulate you on the success you've had with it so far.