Consulting Rainmakers

Nobody followed up on this $22 million pipeline

Jen Kelly · New Initiatives Marketing ·

Jen Kelly is the CEO and Founder of New Initiatives Marketing. This Consulting Rainmakers episode, hosted by Mikulas Zach, is about one idea, in Jen's words: Nobody followed up on this $22 million pipeline.

In this conversation, she explains why the first place to look for growth is the leads already sitting in a company's system, how her team unlocked $22.1 million of stalled opportunities in one client's pipeline, and why AI plus a recent graduate is no substitute for business judgment.

Watch on YouTubeSpotifyApple Podcasts

About Jen Kelly

Jen Kelly spent her early career in corporate marketing at large companies including the Financial Times and Siemens. When the 2008-2009 financial crisis hit, she was laid off from Siemens and planned to freelance until the recession was over, but that division never came back. In 2009 she started New Initiatives Marketing, which began by filling skills gaps inside in-house marketing teams and has grown into a fractional CMO service plus a full marketing team for established B2B companies in oil and gas, electrical power, industrial manufacturing and consulting engineering. Based in Toronto, Jen focuses on the sales enablement end of marketing.

Expect to learn why companies that forget about marketing end up competing on price, why marketing is more than logos on coffee cups, how to follow up without "just bumping this to the top of your inbox", why being taken off a mailing list for not replying puts buyers off, how to use AI to find the blind spots in your own sales calls, why going solo turns a fractional CMO into a commissioned salesperson, and much more…

Jen Kelly: LinkedIn · Website

Chapters

  1. 0:00Cold open
  2. 1:03Welcome
  3. 1:25From A Siemens Layoff To Her Own Firm
  4. 3:14A Fractional CMO Plus A Marketing Team
  5. 6:44Where The Leads Already Are
  6. 9:05The $22.1 Million Nobody Followed Up On
  7. 13:04AI Will Not Replace Judgment
  8. 16:47Using AI To Find Your Blind Spots
  9. 18:52Marketing As A Core Business Function
  10. 20:23Building A Network Of Fractional CMOs
  11. 23:30Where To Find Jen Kelly

Transcript

Machine transcript of the conversation between Jen Kelly and Mikulas Zach, lightly cleaned. Spelling of names and terms may be off.

Mikulas Zach

So joining me today is Jennifer Kelly, the CEO and founder at New Initiatives Marketing. J Jen, thank you for coming on.

Jen Kelly

Absolutely. Thanks for having me.

Mikulas Zach

So to get us going, how did this come together? What's the story of new initiatives marketing?

Jen Kelly

Story of the company. Okay, well, I used to be in corporate marketing, so I used to work in large companies like the Financial Times and Siemens. and back in 2008-2009, there was a financial crisis that happened, and many companies were having a hard time, and a lot of layoffs occurred then. And so I was at Siemens at that time and I was laid off. So I decided I was going to freelance until the recession was over and go right back into working at Siemens. I really liked my job at that time. And fun fact, even to this day, we're recording in 2026, that division never came back. Isn't that amazing? Good thing I didn't wait, right? So throughout freelancing and seeing where some opportunities were in marketing departments of companies, I ended up starting my own company. And how I started is I would go in and you got to think at that time, even with very, very large marketing departments, there's always either a skills gap or there are there is needs for certain things to happen within a campaign or within a project, but they don't need somebody 40 hours a week. But they do need that skill, right? So I started doing that. So kind of triaging or supporting in house marketing comp in house marketing teams. And from there, that's how the company grew. So it started just with me and now it's grown into much larger.

Mikulas Zach

And from what we've been talking about earlier, you have a specific unique model that I think not not a lot of marketing companies have. So could you explain how does it work and what it allows you to do?

Jen Kelly

Sure, yeah. So now, I mean, so 2009, now we're talking in 2026. I mean, many different things have happened within business and and I have had to adapt and as I have built this company we have had to adapt. and so we offer a fractional chief marketing officer, so fractional ch CMO service plus the marketing team. And so what we do is our company focuses on B2B companies within a very set area of industry. So it's oil and gas, electrical power, industrial manufacturing, consulting engineering. Some people joke and say it's all the boring businesses, but we think they're fascinating. So we work with established companies in those areas. And typically what has happened with them is they have grown to a great size. They're doing something really good with a product or service they've invented. And then what happens is they either find competition coming into their area or they want to launch a new product or they want to go into a different geographical market or a different industry. And they're finding that they don't have anything to really differentiate themselves other than lowering their price. And that's simply because they they haven't engaged marketing. They kind of forgot about marketing. They were doing just fine with sales and the referrals and that kind of thing. so when a company gets into that kind of pain, we come in and we create the marketing strategy for them and then we can stay on and execute. And with us in working with companies that haven't engaged marketing and have grown and done really well, some of the some of the hesitation that we come up against is that, you know, well, you know, marketing is just kind of logos on coffee cups. Or it's you know the banners at the trade shows. And so if the leadership team has never been involved in or been at a company where they have seen strategic marketing help the company grow, help sales close faster, then they you know they just don't know what marketing can do. So that's a a lot of our work is to educate on there and and help them. And so with us, You know, you you being with your background in marketing, you understand that marketing has a huge continuum. So if over here is more the branding and the, you know, the p typography and the design and all, you know, the visual side of things or the awareness campaigns, and those are all very important. And then on this side is more about the sales, actually getting the product or service sold. We're more on this side. So we're really looking to come in and help a company's sales team. How can we help you close more deals? How can we help you get more more people to present to? How do we make sure those leads that are coming in are staying warm? So really on the sales enablement side is is where we're at.

Mikulas Zach

Amazing. That's my favorite side. So let's let me ask you the the million dollar question. So how how do you actually generate leads for these businesses? Because I assume I'm not in the industry, but these are very specific type of accounts that these people are targeting. It's not like your your average Joe that goes to the pub on on a Friday. so what's what's been working for you? Do you do LinkedIn advertisements, Google advertisements? What's kind of the mix?

Jen Kelly

I see. Yeah, yeah. It it really depends. And it it's fair to say that because yeah, with the types of products and services that our clients sell, it's yeah, it's not an emotional buy. It's not something that one person can buy on their own. these are products or services that cost a lot of money. There's usually a procurement process or a buying committee or you know, and budget cycles and all that kind of non-emotional stuff around it, right? Very, very practical. so what we do to go in there and you know, LinkedIn ads of work, Google ads of work, that's fine, but but our first look is w what's happening already. one of the main things that happens in the companies that we help, and you know, this is probably happening in all kinds of companies, there are leads there in your system that nobody is following up with. So our first job is to really look at what have you got going right now that we could either reintroduce to the company or start following up and be able to help close those leads. when you have people that already know about your company and people that have already expressed interest in either getting in for more information or, you know, coming into to learn more about your company, that's you know obviously a better a better chance of closing that deal than going out for new ones. So and that's what I mean about us assisting the sales team, right? The like, you know, a great sales team wants to go out and be doing the presentations and closing the the leads and all that kind of stuff. And you know, can you blame if they're forgetting about, you know, keeping things warm. So that's where that's where our first first thing to do is is to look there.

Mikulas Zach

Right. And so is it fair to say that most people are or most of these companies are sitting on stale elites that haven't gotten followed up on? Is that kind of the the gold mine that you usually find in most cases? Is there anything else?

Jen Kelly

It no, it usually is. I I wouldn't say stale, maybe just forgotten about. but but yeah, yeah. I mean it's it's the kind of thing that I mean, and can you blame them, right? Your sales team can only do so much, and you want to make sure your sales team is out there, you know, making the presentation, closing the deals. And so it really falls to marketing to keep those things warm. But yeah, there is, you know, with one company. We unlocked twenty two point one million dollars of stalled opportunities in a pipeline that hadn't been followed up on, right? So there's a lot of money to be had in in helping, you know, helping the sales team get those leads closed.

Mikulas Zach

So how do you go about following up? Because this is I think the constant discussion of people s do you do you use the just bumping up this to your top of the inbox?

Jen Kelly

not if we can help it. like I mean no, just following up. Yeah, yeah, no, no, no. Our writers do much better than that. but the the thing is you have to understand that like as we come in as you know an outside party, we have to understand that our clients have been very successful up until this point doing what they do, right? And so there has to be a lot of respect there as well for their their their their process so far. the other thing is when you get into either supporting sales or into, you know, the sales department, those people have established relationships with these potential clients. it takes a lot of work in order to find, nurture and and sell a client and then resell them depending on the product or service. And so sometimes the sales team is very protective of of their list. So we have to make sure that whatever we're doing, you know, we win their trust with it. And if we are going to be communicating with their clients, just bumping this up to your top of your inbox does nobody any favors. So we we you know we we do a little more sophistication and we're we're we're sure that we care about the the potential lead. Yeah.

Mikulas Zach

Yeah. I I figured, I figured because you know the amounts of people that still send out that kind of message. you know, it's it's it's it's fascinating that it's almost two thousand and twenty-seven. We have AI, you can basically get any kind of information on the internet about the prospect to make the relevant follow up. and people still use these kind of templated things that yeah, I just straight to the bin.

Jen Kelly

You know, I have to tell you if you're gonna talk about that, the one that I think is equally obnoxious is that if you don't reply to somebody's outreach, they're like, Okay, that's it, you're off my mailing list. And it's kind of like, you know what, we I mean, everybody who is in sales wants a sale to close the you know, the first conversation. Of course we all do, right? but but having the company tell me when it's time to buy, tell me that I'm not moving fast enough, so now I go off of their their mailing list, I find that really obnoxious.

Mikulas Zach

Hmm hmm. speaking about obnoxious, what what's your take on AI and marketing and how those kind of tie together? Because I think there's a fine line between what is useful in that regard and what becomes just bumping up to your top of your inbox.

Jen Kelly

I think well, I mean, AI y is here. it has done a lot of great things for our company internally and for some of our clients internally. It's also done a lot of, you know, time wasting. it as well, speaking for us internally, as we we have come up the learning curve and how to use it and what it's good at, what it's not good at. And there's there's a lot of thinking that's that has to go into, you know, making sure that AI can really be helpful for you. yes, we have heard to our faces that you know a client was not gonna hire us. The they will just use AI and someone that has just recently graduated. And you know, although that, you know, it's disappointing and it does hurt, it's the kind of thing that You know, if if the that gives us the the impression that if if you're gonna do that, perhaps you haven't experimented or worked with AI enough to know that it's just like, you know, back in the day, the old fashioned database, the garbage in, garbage out, right? So even if you have top of the class, very enthusiastic, first you're at a school marketing person, How can they how can they actually know about you know the strategy of the whole entire company? Or how can they know about you know many things around business that have taken a long time to learn? Or how do they know if an answer comes back, if that's going to, you know, really impact legal or impact sales in certain ways? They just don't have enough of the the the judgment happening. so we have found that well, it can speed up and well, yeah, we have lost some opportunities to it.

Mikulas Zach

Hm.

Jen Kelly

it's it's our responsibility to make sure that we're showcasing to the client that we've got the expertise, that we've got the judgment, that we've got the ability to help them make the next best decision for their company. And then sure, let's see where AI can can can happen. But for right now, it's it's it's the judgment and the thinking that they're that they they're they're coming to us for.

Mikulas Zach

Yeah, I f I think that's such an important point because AI as its current form, it's so positively inclined to say that you know you're doing everything great, Nick, keep it up, and that everything will work out. But a lot of the times I find that it tells you things that are not true. So it hallucinates a lot. And if you're talking about as you're saying, some of these accounts worth, you know, hundreds of thousands of dollars, maybe even millions, then it's very costly to make such a mistake. So I'm definitely with you on there. what would you say is like your favorite use case? because AI you can use it for Many things, but do you have any kind of you know, your favorite thing?

Jen Kelly

My favorite thing at this time, because I'm sure it's gonna just keep evolving, my favorite thing is to take a transcript of a of a meeting. So you know how you'll have your your note taker or whatever in your meetings, and to run it through AI and ask it what are my blind spots. So I may have thought that I had run either a customer customer meeting. or you know a pre-sale. So we we have a a a call consultation call with a someone that we want to become a client. I think I've done a good job on it. So I run it through AI and asks where my blind spots and it will let me know, you know, there's areas where you should ask more questions here or you totally missed there or this client said, you know, this one sentence that you totally you know did not address. So right now it's i that that's very that's been very, very helpful for me. It's my favorite so far.

Mikulas Zach

Funny that you say that because note takers are I I can't imagine living without them nowadays because when you have the the more calls you take on, the bigger you know th knowledge you have to keep in your brain. And so being able to go and ask AI like after a week or month. about you know what what did you talk about with with with jen it's really useful and it just it's great and you can be more present in the call itself because you don't have to make you know all of the notes so all of those benefits so what would be like your advice to these oil and gas companies if there are listening, besides contacting you, obviously.

Jen Kelly

well, I mean, the the first thing would be, I mean, obviously, you know, we'd like we'd like you know, more business, but to to to really I mean it's very interesting because in business, if you're if you're running a company, there's operations, there's sales, there's there is legal, there's HR, there's different facets that come together to help your company run better. and marketing, I I would like to advise those people to see marketing as as one of those components and really investigate what what marketing can do for for a business. and like I said, you know, earlier in this in this conversation, that's more than just the the visual logos, it really can help to drive business and really can keep you away from discounting your pricing on your products or services. So I would encourage them to look more into how can strategic marketing help their company grow and become much more competitive against their industry.

Mikulas Zach

Yeah, and I think the the bigger picture here is that referrals are great and very valuable, but you cannot plan them. You don't you don't time them. You don't know when when they will come. So it's you know, they get you to a certain point, I think. so s what's what's your vision with the firm? I mean you've been running it for quite some time now.

Jen Kelly

Yeah, I agree.

Mikulas Zach

We're almost into two thousand and twenty seven. Well, so what's your what's on the horizon?

Jen Kelly

On the horizon is to build and strengthen it as it is. And that that means we are constantly on the lookout for experienced fractional CMOs. with the the the understanding at this point in time there are a lot of fractional CMOs out that have been doing great, great work. but one of the things that happens when you go out on your own is not only are you responsible for doing the work, but now you are a hundred percent commissioned salesperson, which many professionals are not aware of that, you know, you go out on your own because you have these great skills and like, no, now I gotta go business develop. And so where we have found a it you know a really great I guess synergy is the fractional CMOs that that we bring in you know they keep their own clients they keep their own structure but we bring them the work so they can be really happy just doing the marketing work, leaving the business development to to us. And so I am looking to have more and more of those types of people on the team so we can go and service more of the mid market ex existing customers and existing clients that are out there. That would be that's that's my goal.

Mikulas Zach

So so what's your go-to-market strategy? Because it seems like you have enough demand. so w how do you go about the marketing for for the firm?

Jen Kelly

we do so yeah we do things on digital. So we have the the website. we make sure the website is set up for AI. We've been getting a number of inquiries where people have said, yeah, you know, ChatGPT mentioned you. So I mean that part is is working. so that's very important. we do a tremendous amount of online n networking. So there's a bunch of organizations and And groups that are virtual that our members are in. And then to be quite honest, it's also the old-fashioned in-person that that I do a lot of. So groups here, I'm based in Toronto. so conferences as well. And and and then there's the old-fashioned cold outreach as well. So I'm always I'm I'm I'm I'm doing that on both sides, right? For potential clients and fractional CMOs.

Mikulas Zach

huh. No, that's amazing. And if people would like to reach out and get in touch with you, what's kind of the the best place to find you and see see more details?

Jen Kelly

well the best place is probably on the the website. So newinitiativesmarketing.com. I think you're gonna have to put that in the show notes because it's such a long name. I'm also available on what's that? I will. Okay, good. I'm also available on LinkedIn, but again, I think there's about five million other Jennifer Kellys out there, to be quite honest. So either the the the website or LinkedIn, be happy to be happy to leave those details there.

Mikulas Zach

I will I will Amazing. Well I found you on LinkedIn, so it's clearly working. so I will leave both links down below and thank you for coming on and sharing your insights.

Jen Kelly

Great. Thanks for the opportunity.